Yıl: 2020 Cilt: 0 Sayı: 14 Sayfa Aralığı: 81 - 98 Metin Dili: İngilizce DOI: 10.18498/amailad.684171 İndeks Tarihi: 20-10-2020

The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent

Öz:
According to the traditionalist Muslim scholars, the history of the denial ofhadīth in the Subcontinent goes back to the 19th century, and they considered SirSyed Ahmad Khan was the first one who challenged the provenance andauthorship of ahādīth. It is a renowned fact that Sir Syed was highly inspired bywestern research about Islam and its primary sources. Hence, he followed thewestern approach to the Prophetic ahādīth in his works and put in question thecodification and the authenticity of hadith. Mulawī Chiragh Ali and his fellowscholars developed and supported his theories with new arguments that laterreached to the denial of hadīth. At that time, the traditionalist Muslim scholarsof the Subcontinent paid attention to this new-born temptation and counteredthe theories of the deniers of hadīth. Syed Mawdūdī was one of them thatadvocated the Prophetic ahādīth through his research journal Tarjamānu'l-Qurān.However, his unique methodology in criticism distinguished him from hiscontemporaneous scholars. Therefore, this study deals with his research andcritical approach to the theories of the deniers of hadīth.
Anahtar Kelime:

Ebu’l A’la Mevdûdî’nin Hint Altkıtası’ndaki Hadis İnkârcılarını Eleştirisi

Öz:
Gelenekçi Müslüman âlimlere göre, Hint Altkıtası’nda hadis inkârcılığının tarihi 19. yüzyıla kadar uzanmaktadır. Onlar, Sör Seyyid Ahmad Han’ı söz konusu bölgede İslam’ın temel kaynaklarından ikincisi olan hadislerin kaynağına ve otoritesine karşı çıkan ilk düşünür olarak kabul ederler. Sör Seyyid Ahmed Han’ın İslam ve onun temel kaynakları hakkındaki görüşlerinde, Batılı araştırmalardan büyük ölçüde etkilendiği bilinen bir gerçektir. O, çalışmalarında Batı’nın nebevî hadislere yaklaşım tarzını takip etmiş, hadislerin kökenini ve gerçekliğini sorgulamıştır. Sör Seyyid Ahmed Han’ın izinden giden Çerağ Ali ve benzeri akademisyenler bu iddiaları, hadislerin reddine götüren yeni argümanlarla geliştirmiş ve desteklemişlerdir. O dönemde Altkıta’nın gelenekçi Müslüman âlimleri, bu yeni doğan harekete dikkat çekmiş ve hadis inkârcılarının teorilerine karşı çıkmışlardır. Bu âlimlerden biri olan Ebu’l-A’la Mevdûdî, bir araştırma dergisi olan Tercemânü’l-Kur’an’da yazdığı yazılarla nebevî hadisleri savunmuş, bununla birlikte, özgün tenkid metodu onu çağdaşı âlimlerden ayırmıştır. Dolayısıyla bu çalışma onun, hadis inkârcılarının iddialarına yönelik araştırmasını ve eleştirel yaklaşımını incelemeyi hedeflemektedir.
Anahtar Kelime:

Belge Türü: Makale Makale Türü: Araştırma Makalesi Erişim Türü: Erişime Açık
  • Abdū’l-Munam al-Namar. Tarikhu’l-Islām fī’l-Hind. Leobnon: alMūasisatu’l-Jāmia, 1981/1401.
  • Abdū’l-Haī. Nūzhatu’l-Khawātir. 8 Volume. Leobnon: Dār Ibn Hazm, 1419/1999.
  • Abdū’l-Munam al-Namar. Kafāhu’l-Muslimīn fī Tahrīr al-Hind. Egypt: alHaīatu’l-Misrīa, 1415/1995.
  • Abdu’r-Raūf Zaffar. Ulum al-Hadīth. Lahore: Nashriāt, 2006/1427.
  • Abdur-Rahmān. Mufakir Islām Syed Abu'l-Ala Mawdūdī. Lahore: Islamic Publications, 1418/1988.
  • Abū’l-Afāq. Abu’l-Ala Mawdūdī Sawānih. Lahore: Islamic Publicatioins, 1390/1971.
  • Abu’l-Ala Mawdūdī. Sunnat kī Ainī Haisīat. Lahore: Islamic Publications, 1423/2003.
  • Abu'l-Ala Mawdūdī. Tafhīmāt. 5 Volume. Lahore: Islamic Publications, 1387/1968.
  • Adams, Charles J. Mawdūdī and the Islamic State. New York: Oxford University Press, 1403/1983.
  • Ahmad Amin. Fajru’l-Islām. Leobnon: Dārū’l-Kutāb al-Arabī, 1969/1388.
  • Ahmad Amin. Zūamāū' l-Islāh fī’l-Asril-Hadīth. Egypt: Hindawī Foundation for Education and Culture, 1433/2012.
  • Asim Numānī. Tassawūf avr Tamīri Sīrat. Lahore: Islamic Publication, 1391/1972.
  • Iftikhār Ahmad. Syed Abu'l-Ala Mawdūdī. Faisal Abad: al-Mizān Publisher, 1421/2001.
  • Irfan Ahmed. The Princeton Encyclopedia of Islamic Political Thought (Collective). United State: Princeton University Press, 1434/2013.
  • Khādim Ilāhī Bakhsh. al-Qurānī’ūn. al-Saūdia: Maktabatū’s-Saddīq, 1420/2000.
  • Khurshid Ahmad - Zafar Ishaq Ansari. Mawlānā Mawdūdī: An Introduction to His Life and Thought. Leicester: Islamic Foundation, 1399/1979.
  • Muhammad Luqmān al-Salafī. Ihtimāmu’l-Muhaddīthīn b-Naqdi’l- Hadīth. India: Markaz al-Allama Abdū’l-Aziz b. Baz, 1420/2000.
  • Roy Jackson. Mawlana Mawdūdī and Political Islam: Authority and the Islamic State. United State: Routledge, 1431/2010.
  • Safeer Akhtar. Adeeb avr Adab. Wah cantt: Dārū’l-Maārif, 1418/1998.
  • Salāhu’d-Din Maqbūl Ahmad. Zawābi fī Wajhī’s-Sunna. India: Majmaū’lBahūs al-Islāmia, 1411/1991.
  • Sir Syed. Maqālāt. 16 Volume. Lahore: Majlis Taraqī Adab, 1404/1984.
  • Suyūtī, Abdūr-Rahmān. Tadrību’r-Ravī. 2 Volume. al-Riyadh: Maktabtū’l-Kavsar, 1415/1995.
  • Syed Sulaimān Nadvī. Arbūn kī Jihāz Ranī. Azamgarh: Dārū’lMusannefīn, 1435/2014.
  • Syed Vali Reza Nasir. Mawdūdī and the Making of Islamic Revivalism. New York: Oxford University Press, 1416/1996.
  • Zebiri, Kate. "Review of Maududi and the making of Islamic fundamentalism". Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies. University of London 61/1 (1998), 167-168.
APA khan A, Kuzudisli A (2020). The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. , 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
Chicago khan Alam,Kuzudisli Ali The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. (2020): 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
MLA khan Alam,Kuzudisli Ali The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. , 2020, ss.81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
AMA khan A,Kuzudisli A The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. . 2020; 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
Vancouver khan A,Kuzudisli A The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. . 2020; 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
IEEE khan A,Kuzudisli A "The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent." , ss.81 - 98, 2020. 10.18498/amailad.684171
ISNAD khan, Alam - Kuzudisli, Ali. "The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent". (2020), 81-98. https://doi.org/10.18498/amailad.684171
APA khan A, Kuzudisli A (2020). The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. Amasya ilahiyat dergisi, 0(14), 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
Chicago khan Alam,Kuzudisli Ali The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. Amasya ilahiyat dergisi 0, no.14 (2020): 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
MLA khan Alam,Kuzudisli Ali The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. Amasya ilahiyat dergisi, vol.0, no.14, 2020, ss.81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
AMA khan A,Kuzudisli A The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. Amasya ilahiyat dergisi. 2020; 0(14): 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
Vancouver khan A,Kuzudisli A The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent. Amasya ilahiyat dergisi. 2020; 0(14): 81 - 98. 10.18498/amailad.684171
IEEE khan A,Kuzudisli A "The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent." Amasya ilahiyat dergisi, 0, ss.81 - 98, 2020. 10.18498/amailad.684171
ISNAD khan, Alam - Kuzudisli, Ali. "The Critique of Abul A'la Mawdudi on the Hadith Deniers in the Indian Subcontinent". Amasya ilahiyat dergisi 14 (2020), 81-98. https://doi.org/10.18498/amailad.684171