A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES

Yıl: 2020 Cilt: 16 Sayı: 188 Sayfa Aralığı: 2169 - 2193 Metin Dili: İngilizce İndeks Tarihi: 11-06-2021

A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES

Öz:
European Union Member States have bilateral tax treaties with one another no relieve double taxation and that are procedures to resolve disputes. However, these procedures are long, costly, and do not always result in a solution. The Union Arbitration Convention provides some relief. However, its scope is limited to the transfer pricing dispute and there is no recourse to repeal the interpretation of the rules. In other words, the existing mechanism such as Mutual Agreement Procedures (MAP) under bilateral tax treaties and EU Arbitration Convention may not always lead to the effective resolution of all relevant tax disputes in a timely manner and show deficiencies in practice. There were a lot of shortcomings in the existing framework. Therefore, the EU adopted Council Directive (EU) 2017/1852 on Tax Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in the European Union. The Directive introduces a mandatory and binding dispute resolution mechanism that is no longer limited to cases of double taxation arising from transfer pricing adjustment and attribution of profit taxpayer permanent establishments. Improved Access to the procedures, increased involvement for the taxpayer, clear and shorter time forms, and obligation for the Member States to implement a solution are the cornerstones of the Directive.
Anahtar Kelime:

AVRUPA BİRLİĞİ VERGİ SORUNLARI ÇÖZÜM MEKANİZMALARINDA ÇOK ÖNEMLİ BİR ADIM; VERGİ UYUŞMAZLIKLARININ ÇÖZÜMLENMESİNDE 2017/1852 SAYILI YENİ DİREKTİFLE İLGİLİ DEĞERLENDİRMELER

Öz:
Avrupa Birliği ülkeleri arasında çifte vergilendirmeden kaynaklanan uyuşmazlıkları çözmek için çeşitli prosedürler geliştirilmiştir. Ancak, bu prosedürler uzun ve maliyetli olup her zaman sorunları çözememiştir. Avrupa Birliği Tahkim Sözleşmesi bu konuda biraz rahatlamasağlamaktaydı. Fakat bu Sözleşmenin kapsamı transfer fiyatlandırmasıanlaşmazlığıyla sınırlıydı. Ayrıca bu konudaki kuralların yorumlanmasını iptal etmek için bir başvuruda da bulunulmamaktaydı. Başka birdeyişle, eski sistem-mekanizma (Avrupa Birliği Tahkim Sözleşmesi, ikilivergi antlaşmalarına bağlı çözüm yolları gibi) her zaman etkili bir sonuçdoğuramamaktaydı. Pratikte zamanlama açısından yetersizlikler görüldüğü gibi eski çözüm şeması da bir çok sorunu çözmekte yetersiz kalmıştır.Bundan dolayı Avrupa Birliği 2017/1852 Nolu Direktifini kabul etmişir. Direktif, özellikle transfer fiyatlandırması ve benzeri vergisel işlemlerden kaynaklanan vergi uyuşmazlıklarının azaltılması için zorunluçözüm yolları getirmiştir. Prosedürlere erişimin kolaylaşması mükelleflerin sisteme olan katılımını artmıştır. Ayrıca konuyla ilgili kurallar daha açık hale getirilmiş ve zamanlama ile ilgili düzenlemeler kısa tutulmuştur. Direktifle getirilen bu temel düzenlemelere uyulması zorunludur.
Anahtar Kelime:

Belge Türü: Makale Makale Türü: Araştırma Makalesi Erişim Türü: Bibliyografik
  • Capital Gains Tax, Corporation Tax, Income Tax in The UK-The Double Taxation Dispute Resolution (EU) Regulations 2014
  • COUNCIL DIRECTIVE on Tax Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in The European Union,2017/1852, Official Journal of the European Union 265/1, 14.October 2017
  • Deloitte, International Tax, 26 May 2017
  • Ernest and Young, Tax Dispute Resolution; A New Chapter Emerges, 2011
  • European Economic and Social Committee,c 173/29,31.05.2017
  • European Economic and Social Committee, Opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee on the proposal for a Council Directive on Double Taxation Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in European Union, Official Journal of European Union 31.05.2017
  • EU İnsights, New EU-Wive System to Resolve Tax Disputes Between the Member States, https://europost.eu/en/a/view/new-eu-wide-system-to resolve-tax disputes-between-m...,26.07.2019
  • European Parliamentary Research Service, Double Taxation Dispute Resolution Mechanism in the European Union, EU Legislation in Progress, February 2017
  • European Parliamentary Research Service, Double Taxation Dispute Resolution Mechanisms in The European Union, EU Legislation in Progress, February 2017
  • Hugh Ault, Dispute Resolution, The Mutual Agreement Procedure, Papers on Selected Topics in Administration of Tax Treaties for Developing Countries, İtc, Paper No. 8-A May 2013
  • http://knowledge.freshfields.com/cp/global/3704/international_tax _arbitration_oec, 26.07.2017
  • InternationalTaxArbitration;OECDandEUDevelopments, http:// knowledge. freshields.com/cp,Global/r/3704/international_tax_arbitration_ oec. 26.07.2019
  • İnternational Tax Glossary, İBFD, Netherland, Seventh Edition, 2015
  • Mooij H, ‘Tax Treaty Arbitration’ (June 2018) 35 (2) Arbitration İnternational
  • OECD, Appointing Authorities, and Selection of Arbitrations in İnvestor-State Dispute Settlement; An Overview, Consultation Paper, March 2018
  • Official Journal of The European Union,c 173/29, 31.05.2017
  • Owens J, ‘Mandotary Tax Arbitration: The Next Frontier İssue’ (2018) 46 (8 and 9) İntertax
  • PİT MARK HARM, Dispute Resolution in EU, The EU Arbitration Convention and Dispute Resolution Directive, IBFD Doctoral Series 42, Amsterdam,2018
  • PİT M.H, ‘The Changed Landscape of Tax Dispute Resolution Within the EU; Consideration of Directive on Tax Dispute Resolution Mechanism’ (2019) 47 (8 and 9) İntertax
  • Pitrowski S, İsmer R, Baker P, Monsene J, Porrou K, Petruzzi R, Reimer E, Anton Serrano Fernandoi Stankiewill W, Treversa E and Woje J, ‘Towards a standing Committee Pursuant to Article 10 of the EU Tax Dispute Resolution Directive: A Proposal for İmlemantation’ (2019) 47 (8 and 9) İntertax
  • PWC, EU Directive on Tax Dispute Resolution Mechanism Formally Adopted, 11. October 2012, www.pwc.com/eudlg, 29.07.2019.
  • Pwc, Tax İnsights, İncreased Taxpayer Rights For Tax Dispute Resolution Under New EU Directive, 2017.
  • PWC, Tax İnsight, From Tax Controversy and Dispute Resolution İncreased Taxpayer Rights For Tax Dispute Resolution Under New EU Directive, 2019.
  • SCHWARZ, EU Sets the Standart for İnternational Tax Dispute Resolution, http://kluvertaxblog.com/category/archives/arbitration/?print =print-search
  • SCHWARZ JONATHAN, Tax Dispute Resolution Directive: An İmportant Step for The EU, http://kluwertaxblog.com/category/archives/ arbitration/2print=print-search
  • Waincymer J, Procedure and Evidence in the İnternational Arbitration (Netherlands Wolter Kluwer 2012)
  • Mcintyre J. Micheal, Comments on the OECD for Secret and Mandatory Arbitration of İnternational Tax Disputes, Wayne State University Law School Legal Studies Research Paper Series no:07:05; April 2008, http://ssrn.com/abstract=895633
  • Zeyen G, ‘When Taxation Meets Arbitration: Recent İnitiatives to İntroduce and Promete Arbitration İn İnternational and European Taxation’ (2017) 45 (II) İntertax
APA Nas A (2020). A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. , 2169 - 2193.
Chicago Nas Adil A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. (2020): 2169 - 2193.
MLA Nas Adil A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. , 2020, ss.2169 - 2193.
AMA Nas A A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. . 2020; 2169 - 2193.
Vancouver Nas A A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. . 2020; 2169 - 2193.
IEEE Nas A "A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES." , ss.2169 - 2193, 2020.
ISNAD Nas, Adil. "A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES". (2020), 2169-2193.
APA Nas A (2020). A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. Legal Mali Hukuk Dergisi, 16(188), 2169 - 2193.
Chicago Nas Adil A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. Legal Mali Hukuk Dergisi 16, no.188 (2020): 2169 - 2193.
MLA Nas Adil A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. Legal Mali Hukuk Dergisi, vol.16, no.188, 2020, ss.2169 - 2193.
AMA Nas A A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. Legal Mali Hukuk Dergisi. 2020; 16(188): 2169 - 2193.
Vancouver Nas A A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES. Legal Mali Hukuk Dergisi. 2020; 16(188): 2169 - 2193.
IEEE Nas A "A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES." Legal Mali Hukuk Dergisi, 16, ss.2169 - 2193, 2020.
ISNAD Nas, Adil. "A VERY IMPORTANT STEP ON THE RESOLUTIONMECHANISMS OF TAX DISPUTES IN THE EUROPEANUNION: ASSESMENT OF THE 2017/1852 NUMBERED DIRECTIVE ON THE RESOLUTION OF TAX DISPUTES". Legal Mali Hukuk Dergisi 16/188 (2020), 2169-2193.