Sheikh Shuca Al-din, whose life is full of mysteries, has a book called Walayat-nama, which is believedto be published by one of his disciples. In this book, his name appears as ‘Sultan Varlığı’. What is knownabout this sheikh, who is a wandering dervish travelling especially around Western Anatolia, is mostlylimited to his book Walayat-nama. By analyzing the historical characters in the book and eliminatingthe myths about his life and personality, it can be assumed that he lived during the end of 14th andbeginning of 15th centuries.Sheikh Shuca, one of the most important people of the Abdalan-i Rûm group, is buried in a villageof Seyitgazi, Eskişehir, which is named after him. The aim of this article is to present the findings andevaluations of the section in which the text of the Walayat-nama is published in Yagmur Say’s book aboutthe Walayat-nama of Sheikh Shuca al-din, the book published in 2010. The findings and evaluation willbe presented under two main headings: the deficiencies and mistakes in the “text writing process” inthe publication of the work, and the erroneous readings we have found in the text. The reading mistakesare presented in a table in which a column explains where the mistake is, along with a cue that thereader passes through without being torn from the context of the words in order to facilitate retrieval.